Mental health nursing and the negotiated order of professions: A critical analysis of psychotherapy discourses in Québec (Canada)
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Access to mental health care remains a pressing global issue. In response, policymakers have devised strategies that span from self-care to psychotherapy, hoping to ease the strain. However, reforms over the past two decades have significantly restricted access to psychotherapy, limiting the number of professionals, such as nurses, allowed to practise under stringent conditions. This article examines the effects of Quebec’s public policies on the practice of psychotherapy and mental health interventions. A critical discourse analysis, grounded in Strauss’s theory of negotiated order, was conducted on 48 policy documents and public discourses. The findings reveal that mental health interventions have become disconnected from their therapeutic essence, reduced instead to technical tasks. This shift perpetuates a hierarchical professional landscape, subordinating these practices despite their reliance on the relational dynamics that define effective mental health care. For the nursing profession, the implications are profound. The profession’s contribution to providing timely access to community-based mental health services is being overlooked, stymied by outdated perceptions and policy restrictions.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
References
Adam, S., Gold, E. et Burstow, B. (2023). From subjective opinion to medical fact: A critical discourse analysis of mental health nursing education. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 44(1), 55-63. https://doi.org/10.1080/01612840.2022.2113940
Allain, S. (2004). La négociation comme concept analytique central d’une théorie de la régulation sociale. Négociations, 2(2), 23-40. https://doi.org/10.3917/neg.002.023
Allen, D. (1997). The nursing‐medical boundary: a negotiated order?. Sociology of Health & Illness, 19(4), 498-520. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9566.1997.tb00415.x
American Psychological Association. (2024). Manualized therapy. https://dictionary.apa.org/manualized-therapy
Arribas-Ayllon, M. et Walkerdine, V. (2017). Foucauldian discourse analysis. Dans C. Willig et W. Stainton Rogers (dir.), The SAGE Handbook of Qualitative Research in Psychology (2e ed., p. 110-123). SAGE Publishing.
Association canadienne de counselling et de psychothérapie. (2023). La profession et la règlementation. https://www.ccpa-accp.ca/fr/la-reglementation-au-canada/
Barry, S. et Ward, L. (2017). Undergraduate nursing students' understandings of mental health: A review of the literature. Issues in Mental Health Nursing, 38(2), 160-175. https://doi.org/10.1080/01612840.2016.1251515
Benjamin, L. T. Jr. (2005). A history of clinical psychology as a profession in America (and a glimpse at its future). Annual Review of Clinical Psychology, 1, 1-30. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.clinpsy.1.102803.143758
Brodeur, N., Roy, V., Lindsay, J., Tremblay, G. et Damant, D. (2015). Une critique de la définition de la psychothérapie au Québec. Nouvelles pratiques sociales, 27(2), 295-308. https://doi.org/10.7202/1037694ar
Buchanan, R. D. (2003). Legislative warriors: American psychiatrists, psychologists, and competing claims over psychotherapy in the 1950s. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences, 39(3), 225-249. https://doi.org/10.1002/jhbs.10113
Castelpietra, G., Simon, J., Gutiérrez-Colosía, M. R., Rosenberg, S. et Salvador-Carulla, L. (2021). Disambiguation of psychotherapy: a search for meaning. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 219(4), 532-537. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.2020.196
Commission de la santé mentale du Canada. (2017). Faire valoir les arguments en faveur des investissements dans le système de santé mentale du Canada à l’aide de considérations économiques. https://www.mentalhealthcommission.ca/wp-content/uploads/drupal/2017-03/case_for_investment_fr.pdf
Champagne, F., Contandriopoulos, A.P., Ste-Marie, G. et Chartrand, E. (2018). L’accessibilité aux services de santé et aux services sociaux au Québec : Portrait de la situation. https://www.bibliotheque.assnat.qc.ca/DepotNumerique_v2/AffichageFichier.aspx?idf=184199
Côté, M.A. et Brodeur, N. (2019). Impacts des nouvelles modalités d’encadrement de la psychothérapie chez les travailleurs sociaux. Recherches sociographiques, 60(2), 351-378. https://doi.org/10.7202/1070975ar
Cuijpers, P., Reijnders, M. et Huibers, M. J. (2019). The role of common factors in psychotherapy outcomes. Annual review of clinical psychology, 15, 207-231. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-050718-095424
Fleury, M. J. (2014). La réforme des soins primaires de santé mentale au Québec et le rôle et les stratégies de coordination des omnipraticiens. Santé mentale au Québec, 39(1), 25-45 https://doi.org/10.7202/1025905ar
Foucault, M. (2012). Du Gouvernement des vivants Cours au Collège de France (1979-1980). Gallimard.
Garon-Sayegh, P. (2016). Quebec professional law as an obstacle to interprofessional care [Mémoire de maîtrise en droit, Université McGill]. eScholarship. https://escholarship.mcgill.ca/concern/theses/cc08hj21w
Gouvernement du Québec. (2009). Loi modifiant le Code des professions et d’autres dispositions législatives dans le domaine de la santé mentale et des relations humaines. Publications du Québec. https://www.publicationsduquebec.gouv.qc.ca/fileadmin/Fichiers_client/lois_et_reglements/LoisAnnuelles/fr/2009/2009C28F.PDF
Groupe en éthique de la recherche. (2018). Énoncé de politique des trois conseils : Éthique de la recherche avec des êtres humains.
Gouvernement du Canada. https://ethics.gc.ca/fra/policy-politique_tcps2-eptc2_2018.html
Happell, B. (2010). Moving in circles: A brief history of reports and inquiries relating to mental health content in undergraduate nursing curricula. Nurse Education Today, 30(7), 643-648. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2009.12.018
Hurley, J., Lakeman, R., Cashin, A., et Ryan, T. (2020). The remarkable (Disappearing Act of the) mental health nurse psychotherapist. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 29(4), 652-660. https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.12698
Hurley, J., et Lakeman, R. (2021). Making the case for clinical mental health nurses to break their silence on the healing they create: A critical discussion. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 30(2), 574-582. https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.12836
Karasu, T. B. (1992). The worst of times, the best of times: Psychotherapy in the 1990s. The Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research, 1(1), 2-15.
Khan, T. H. et MacEachen, E. (2021). Foucauldian discourse analysis: Moving beyond a social constructionist analytic. International journal of qualitative methods, 20, 16094069211018009. https://doi.org/10.1177/16094069211018009
Kidd, S. A., Davidson, L. et McKenzie, K. (2017). Common factors in community mental health intervention: a scoping review. Community Mental Health Journal, 53, 627-637 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10597-017-0117-8
Lakeman, R., Foster, K., Happell, B., Hazelton, M., Moxham, L., et Hurley, J. (2024). Informing the development of a fit‐for‐purpose mental health nursing curriculum: A survey of mental health nurse academics in Australia. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 33(1), 93-103. https://doi.org/10.1111/inm.13226
Lapalme, M., Moreault, B., Fansi, A., et Jehanno C. (2018). Accès équitable aux services de psychothérapie au Québec : État des connaissances. Institut national d’excellence en santé et en services sociaux. https://www.inesss.qc.ca/fileadmin/doc/INESSS/Rapports/ServicesSociaux/INESSS_Acces-equitable-psychotherapie.pdf
Lebrun-Paré, F., Mantoura, P. et Roberge, M. C. (2023). Proposition d'un modèle conceptuel concernant la surveillance de la santé mentale, des troubles mentaux courants et de leurs déterminants au Québec. Institut national de santé publique du Québec. https://www.inspq.qc.ca/publications/3365
Lego, S. (1973). Nurse psychotherapists: how are we different?. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care, 11(4), 144-147. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6163.1973.tb00815.x
Mignogna, J., Martin, L. A., Harik, J., Hundt, N. E., Kauth, M., Naik, A. D., … et Cully, J. (2018). “I had to somehow still be flexible”: exploring adaptations during implementation of brief cognitive behavioral therapy in primary care. Implementation Science, 13(1), 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13012-018-0768-z
Mimeault, V. (2016). Projet de Loi 21 de 2009 et identité professionnelle de travailleurs sociaux œuvrant en santé mentale jeunesse [Mémoire de maîtrise en travail social, Université du Québec à Montréal]. Archipel. https://archipel.uqam.ca/9400/
Ministère de la Santé et des Services sociaux du Québec. (2023). Tableau de bord - Performance du réseau de la santé et des services sociaux. Gouvernement du Québec. https://www.quebec.ca/sante/systeme-et-services-de-sante/organisation-des-services/donnees-systeme-sante-quebecois-services/performance-reseau-sante-services-sociaux
Moroz, N., Moroz, I., et D’Angelo, M. S. (2020). Mental health services in Canada: barriers and cost-effective solutions to increase access. Healthcare management forum, 33(6), 282-287. https://doi.org/10.1177/0840470420933911
Ordre des infirmières et des infirmiers du Québec. (2023). Rapport statistique sur l’effectif infirmier et la relève infirmière du Québec 2022-2023. https://www.oiiq.org/documents/20147/26586017/oiiq-rapport-statistique-23-VF.pdf/6f710838-6645-eef2-90f6-152b5400d34a
Ordre des psychologues du Québec. (2023). Rapport annuel 2022-2023. https://www.ordrepsy.qc.ca/documents/26707/501029/RapportAnnuel_2022-2023_Projet+pour+consultation.pdf/3051c81c-1f01-4d86-6ae8-b984540eb179?t=1689002291024
Organisation mondiale de la santé. (2022). Plan d’action global pour la santé mentale 2013-2030. https://www.who.int/fr/publications-detail/9789240031029
Pariseau-Legault, P., Ayala, R.A., Labrecque-Lebeau, L., Vallée-Ouimet, S., Bujold, A., & Gervais, C. (2024). La pratique infirmière en santé mentale et l’ordre négocié des professions : analyse des discours publics portant sur l’encadrement de la psychothérapie au Québec (Canada). Revue l’Infirmière Clinicienne, 21(1), 1-20.
Prud’homme, J. (2014). Professions à part entière: histoire des ergothérapeutes, orthophonistes, physiothérapeutes, psychologues et travailleuses sociales au Québec. Presses de l’Université de Montréal.
Rivero-Santana, A., Perestelo-Perez, L., Alvarez-Perez, Y., Ramos-Garcia, V., Duarte-Diaz, A., Linertova, R., … et PECUNIA Group. (2021). Stepped care for the treatment of depression: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of affective disorders, 294, 391-409. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2021.07.008
Roy, C. (2016). Affirmation de la profession: Quels sont les défis pour les psychologues québécois?. Psychologie Canadienne, 57(3), 220-225. https://doi.org/10.1037/cap0000052
Sam, C. H. (2019). Shaping discourse through social media: Using Foucauldian discourse analysis to explore the narratives that influence educational policy. American Behavioral Scientist, 63(3), 333-350. https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764218820565
Shedler, J. (2020). Where is the evidence for “evidence-based” therapy?. Dans M. Leuzinger-Bohleber, M. Solms et S.E. Arnold (dir.) Outcome research and the future of psychoanalysis (p. 44-56). Taylor & Francis.
Strauss, A. (1992a). L’hôpital et son ordre négocié. Dans I. Baszanger (dir.) La trame de la négociation (p. 87-112). L’Harmattan.
Strauss, A. (1992b). Négociations. Introduction à la question. Dans I. Baszanger (dir.) La trame de la négociation (p. 245-268). L’Harmattan.
Szasz, T. S. (1974). The myth of psychotherapy. American journal of psychotherapy, 28(4), 517-526. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.psychotherapy.1974.28.4.517
Trudeau, J. B., Desjardins, P., & Dion, A. (2015). Psychothérapie–Un encadrement nécessaire et légalement reconnu au Québec. Santé mentale au Québec, 40(4), 31-42. https://doi.org/10.7202/1036091ar
Truijens, F., Zühlke‐van Hulzen, L. et Vanheule, S. (2019). To manualize, or not to manualize: Is that still the question? A systematic review of empirical evidence for manual superiority in psychological treatment. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 75(3), 329-343. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.22712
Ujhely, G. B. (1973). The nurse as psychotherapist: what are the issues?. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care, 11(4), 155-160. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6163.1973.tb00817.x
Warin, P. (2017). Le non-recours aux politiques sociales. Presses universitaires de Grenoble.
Wiener, D. N. (1953). Some legislative and legal problems of psychologists. American Psychologist, 8(10), 564–569. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0055621